I've been contemplating this post for a good while. But I've put off writing it, both because it's about something that's very important to me and because it's something that's very hard to put into words.
For many years, I've been aware of a contradiction in my own personality. Temperamentally I'm a pessimist, but philosophically (for want of a better word) I'm an optimist.
When it comes to my own life and experiences, I nearly always expect to be disappointed. I nearly always anticipate that things won't work. This extends to very mundane things. If I make a joke and somebody laughs, I'm both delighted and amazed. (People who have heard my jokes will probably say this is entirely justified.)
But it extends to bigger things, as well. Don't ask me who's going to win the next big election or referendum that we all care about. My answer is always: "The side that I'd like to see lose."
Similarly, the current indications of a revival of Christianity flabbergast me. I didn't expect to see this in my lifetime.
So I'm a pessimist by nature. And yet I've never been attracted to philosophical (or artistic) pessimism.
I've generally been drawn to optimistic art and entertainment. For instance, Star Trek, which is not only optimistic but downright utopian. Or Groundhog Day, which is all about a cynical jerk learning to appreciate the beauty of everyday and ordinary. Or the US version of The Office, which is deeply sentimental and upbeat under its upper layer of cringe comedy. Or the "Fanfare for the Makers" section from Louis MacNeice's Autumn Journal.
(Not that I never like pessimistic entertainment. But I like it as an astringent cordial.)
The last day of the twentieth century was a big day for me, because I won a millennium poetry competition organized by ITV Teletext. My poem drew on Lord Alfred Tennyson's famous "New Year's bells" section from In Memoriam-- "Ring out the thousand wars of old, ring out the thousand years of peace"-- and contrasted it with the horrors of the twentieth century. But it ended on a defiantly hopeful note:
Ring out, wild bells, to the wild sky--
Though every hope may be disproved
May none see through such jaundiced eye
As to regard this night unmoved--
Although so many a New Year peal
Brought forth so many a hope untrue
Still whisper with unvanquished zeal
Ring out the old, ring in the new;
Ring in the new, ring out the old;
For who can say that hopes are vain?
And if they fail a thousandfold
May others hope them all again.
So I'm a pessimist by nature but an optimist by choice.
In some ways, being a thoroughgoing pessimist leads to an optimistic view of the world-- or, at least, a relatively approving view of the world. Things are never quite as bad as a pessimist expects (most of the time). If you are not currently living through war, famine, plague, or anarchy-- well, things could be much worse.
(There's an amusing illustration of this in a Tom Sharpe novel-- one of the WIlt novels, though I forget which one. Wilt describes Lord of the Flies as a sickeningly sentimental novel, since the author actually seems surprised and outraged that an island of schoolboys would descend to barbarity!)
But this route to optimism from pessimism isn't just a reaction to circumstances, at least in my case. It's a reaction to the underlying conditions of existence. For instance, I've often found myself feeling grateful for the fact that most of us, most of the time, confidently expect to live another day and another year. I can imagine a world where this wasn't the case, not just in times of war or sickness but in times of peace and health. What if all human life was literally as precarious as a war-zone?
The poetry of Louis MacNeice nourished (and expressed) this sense of pessimistic optimism, or pessimistic gratitude. But don't worry, I'm not going to divert into MacNeice just now.
As you can imagine, the discovery of G.K. Chesterton in my late twenties was an epoch in my life. Principally because Chesterton carried me over the finish line of faith in Christianity, but also because he vindicated and amplified this innate sense of gratitude and wonder, under all my pessimism.
Out of dozens of possible Chesterton passages I could quote, the "abyss of light" passage from Chaucer might be the best: "There is at the back of all our lives an abyss of light, more blinding and unfathomable than any abyss of darkness; and it is the abyss of actuality, of existence, of the fact that things truly are, and that we ourselves are incredibly and sometimes almost incredulously real. It is the fundamental fact of being, as against not being; it is unthinkable, yet we cannot unthink it, though we may sometimes be unthinking about it; unthinking and especially unthanking. For he who has realized this reality knows that it does outweigh, literally to infinity, all lesser regrets or arguments for negation, and that under all our grumblings there is a subconscious substance of gratitude."
Al of this, however, is a sort of prologue to what I really wanted to write.
I really wanted to write about bliss-- an underlying sense of bliss which has accompanied me all my life, as far as I can remember. Even in the shadow of my general pessimism and melancholy.
More than anything else, this bliss resembles a faint music which can just about be heard, or which comes in and out of hearing, and which underlies everything.
When I look back at my infancy and childhood, I remember a lot of boredom and frustration and other negative emotions-- but all the time, shot through with the sense of bliss underlying everything.
This sense of bliss seems like both an underlying reality and an anticipation, an anticipation of something unspeakably wonderful which throws every other joy and happiness into the shade.
I'm sure this is a common human feeling, even among atheists and secularists-- hence the many social philosophies that beckon us towards a heaven on earth, or which "immanentize the eschaton". Of course, for religious believers, it's a premonition of Heaven, or the Beatific Vision, or some equivalent. In the words of Tennyson, it's:
That far-off, divine event
To which the whole creation moves.
I'm sure that almost all of my readers are thinking of C.S. Lewis and "Joy" right now-- as well they might. There's an obvious resemblance between the "bliss" I'm describing here and the Joy that Lewis has described so well. If there's a difference, it might be that Joy seemed to be a fairly rare experience for Lewis, while the "bliss" I'm describing is more habitual. (I might be wrong about that.) I'll come back to Lewis and Joy later.
Where Lewis had his Joy, Wordsworth had his "spots of time". I'm not saying all these experiences are the same, they certainly resemble each other.
(Honest to God, I didn't use the term "bliss" to differentiate it from Lewis's "Joy". I wasn't even thinking of the Lewis comparison when I started writing this post!)
If this sense of bliss was all anticipation, it might be seen as a curse-- a sort of evolutionary carrot on a string to keep us soldering on through the hardships of life.
But it's not just that. It's as much a bliss in things as they are as it is looking forward to some future happiness. In fact, both seem linked to me: every moment of bliss seems like a beacon towards some ultimate bliss.
C.S. Lewis, in a famous passage that is always worth quoting, lists a few triggers (if I dare use that word?) of Joy: "the smell of a bonfire, the sound of wild ducks flying overhead, the title of The Well at the World’s End, the opening lines of Kubla Khan, the morning cobwebs in late summer, or the noise of falling waves."
I have my own list of triggers when it comes to bliss:
The titles of various films, books, albums, etc. For instance, The Road to Wigan Pier or Mornings in the Dark or "There is a Light That Never Goes Out".
Particular words and phrases. ("The dead of night", "The middle of nowhere", "The old, old story..")
The hum of voices on the air, especially in a place in which a current of life is always passing through: a hotel lobby, an airport concourse, etc.. Or the hum of voices in the air at a special event such as an election count centre, a conference, a convention, an open day, or so forth.
Anything to do with the iconography, symbolism, and associations of the cinema; the stylized image of a reel of celluloid, an old-fashioned cinema marquee, a TV presenter addressing the camera in an empty cinema, studio logos, and so on.
Every stylized symbol that is used to evoke a whole atmosphere; such as a lit cityscape at night for the Big City, or a cartoon palm tree for reggae music, or a glitterball for the seventies.
The sounds that water-pipes make; tapping, the whistling of wind, gurgling, and so forth. Along with many other sounds.
Anything that evokes "the drunkenness of things being various", as Louis MacNeice so memorably put it. For instance, the Trivial Pursuit board.
Anything that evokes a tradition; a Halloween bonfire, a Chrismas tree, an Advent wreath, a menorah, etc.
Various idents, such as this one, and this one, (The Carlton one brings back happy memories of my peak cinema-going days, in my early twenties.)
I could go on and on. Indeed, I doubt I'll resist the temptation of adding to this list in the future.
But you get the picture, and I may as well end it there. I hope I have explained, to some extent at least, how I can regard myself as a melancholy pessimist who still exults in the gift of life, the magic of existence itself.